diff --git a/_tutorials/multiphysics/Static_FSI.md b/_tutorials/multiphysics/Static_FSI.md index ef001f05..38404e67 100644 --- a/_tutorials/multiphysics/Static_FSI.md +++ b/_tutorials/multiphysics/Static_FSI.md @@ -259,30 +259,23 @@ which will show the following convergence history: +----------------------------------------------------------------+ | Outer_Iter| avg[bgs][0]| avg[bgs][1]|MinVolume[0]|DeformIter[0| +----------------------------------------------------------------+ -| 0| -0.298306| -2.057930| 8.8212e-10| 0| -| 1| -1.233707| -2.461095| 8.7251e-10| 44| -| 2| -1.873187| -2.756673| 8.7582e-10| 44| -| 3| -2.318032| -3.063910| 8.7469e-10| 44| -| 4| -2.779761| -3.367198| 8.7509e-10| 44| -| 5| -3.234473| -3.671810| 8.7495e-10| 44| -| 6| -3.691477| -3.975951| 8.7500e-10| 44| -| 7| -4.147655| -4.280253| 8.7498e-10| 44| -| 8| -4.604089| -4.584496| 8.7498e-10| 44| -| 9| -5.060508| -4.888768| 8.7498e-10| 44| -| 10| -5.516800| -5.193024| 8.7498e-10| 44| -| 11| -5.972522| -5.497350| 8.7498e-10| 44| -| 12| -6.430557| -5.802173| 8.7498e-10| 44| -| 13| -6.887166| -6.107626| 8.7498e-10| 44| -| 14| -7.332413| -6.412442| 8.7498e-10| 44| -| 15| -7.786647| -6.715388| 8.7498e-10| 44| -| 16| -8.241665| -7.018034| 8.7498e-10| 44| -| 17| -8.696447| -7.320767| 8.7498e-10| 44| -| 18| -9.150914| -7.623596| 8.7498e-10| 44| -| 19| -9.605232| -7.926468| 8.7498e-10| 44| -| 20| -10.059523| -8.229348| 8.7498e-10| 44| -| 21| -10.513823| -8.532227| 8.7498e-10| 44| -| 22| -10.968128| -8.835097| 8.7498e-10| 44| -| 23| -11.422397| -9.137915| 8.7498e-10| 44| +| 0| -0.298306| -2.048554| 8.8212e-10| 0| +| 1| -1.221569| -2.661506| 8.7196e-10| 44| +| 2| -2.176547| -3.088096| 8.7369e-10| 44| +| 3| -2.822207| -3.526246| 8.7331e-10| 44| +| 4| -3.479962| -3.962556| 8.7339e-10| 44| +| 5| -4.134404| -4.399315| 8.7337e-10| 44| +| 6| -4.789556| -4.835974| 8.7338e-10| 44| +| 7| -5.444539| -5.272643| 8.7338e-10| 44| +| 8| -6.099727| -5.709490| 8.7338e-10| 44| +| 9| -6.756832| -6.147703| 8.7338e-10| 44| +| 10| -7.393475| -6.578762| 8.7338e-10| 44| +| 11| -8.032563| -7.003230| 8.7338e-10| 44| +| 12| -8.670813| -7.426572| 8.7338e-10| 44| +| 13| -9.309448| -7.851164| 8.7338e-10| 44| +| 14| -9.949022| -8.277094| 8.7338e-10| 44| +| 15| -10.588983| -8.703770| 8.7338e-10| 44| +| 16| -11.228939| -9.130581| 8.7338e-10| 44| ``` The code is stopped as soon as the values of ```avg[bgs][0]``` and ```avg[bgs][1]``` are below the convergence criteria set in the config file. @@ -313,20 +306,19 @@ to the FSI master config file. Running SU2 now would result in the following con +----------------------------------------------------------------+ | Outer_Iter| avg[bgs][0]| avg[bgs][1]|MinVolume[0]|DeformIter[0| +----------------------------------------------------------------+ -| 0| -0.298306| -2.057930| 8.8212e-10| 0| -| 1| -1.328468| -2.545969| 8.4294e-10| 44| -| 2| -2.534408| -3.682943| 8.6847e-10| 44| -| 3| -3.191063| -4.589793| 8.7367e-10| 44| -| 4| -3.914158| -5.005570| 8.7472e-10| 44| -| 5| -4.607760| -5.801215| 8.7493e-10| 44| -| 6| -5.312537| -6.111128| 8.7497e-10| 44| -| 7| -6.011509| -6.646911| 8.7498e-10| 44| -| 8| -6.713854| -7.336080| 8.7498e-10| 44| -| 9| -7.420407| -7.562424| 8.7498e-10| 44| -| 10| -8.120180| -8.055230| 8.7498e-10| 44| -| 11| -8.821508| -8.532547| 8.7498e-10| 44| -| 12| -9.521912| -9.019092| 8.7498e-10| 44| - +| 0| -0.298306| -2.048554| 8.8212e-10| 0| +| 1| -1.316281| -2.740561| 8.4063e-10| 44| +| 2| -2.215592| -3.528252| 8.6618e-10| 44| +| 3| -3.014938| -4.639836| 8.7192e-10| 44| +| 4| -3.732471| -5.402349| 8.7309e-10| 44| +| 5| -4.436227| -5.790750| 8.7332e-10| 44| +| 6| -5.137723| -6.263485| 8.7337e-10| 44| +| 7| -5.840368| -6.711814| 8.7338e-10| 44| +| 8| -6.536232| -7.339662| 8.7338e-10| 44| +| 9| -7.247336| -7.555240| 8.7338e-10| 44| +| 10| -7.946736| -8.297281| 8.7338e-10| 44| +| 11| -8.648240| -8.586354| 8.7338e-10| 44| +| 12| -9.353917| -9.043231| 8.7338e-10| 44| ``` where the -9 convergence parameter is reached in almost half the iterations as per the non-relaxed case. @@ -371,23 +363,23 @@ in ```config_channel.cfg``` to limit the printout to every 10 iterations. The re +-----------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | Outer_Iter| Inner_Iter| rms[U]| rms[R]| rms[E]| VonMises| +-----------------------------------------------------------------------------+ -| 0| 0| -1.172239| -2.720505| -4.519976| 2.0796e+03| -| 0| 1| -1.818490| 1.181466| -1.921389| 2.0398e+03| -| 0| 2| -2.637505| 0.417532| -3.589310| 2.1346e+03| -| 0| 3| -2.582883| -1.193130| -5.577934| 1.9673e+03| -| 0| 4| -3.571091| -1.385185| -7.138344| 1.9576e+03| -| 0| 5| -3.760354| -2.702330| -9.178542| 1.9592e+03| -| 0| 6| -4.723581| -3.572916| -11.185106| 1.9596e+03| -| 0| 7| -6.588695| -5.625140| -15.057476| 1.9596e+03| -| 0| 8| -10.508431| -9.374250| -22.787668| 1.9596e+03| -| 0| 9| -16.135784| -11.615447| -28.539041| 1.9596e+03| +| 0| 0| -1.121561| -2.706864| -4.419338| 2.2876e+03| +| 0| 1| -1.708123| 1.269382| -1.716845| 2.2429e+03| +| 0| 2| -2.583705| 0.631041| -3.175890| 2.2237e+03| +| 0| 3| -2.508726| -0.795411| -5.686295| 2.0701e+03| +| 0| 4| -2.751613| -1.306797| -6.550284| 2.0544e+03| +| 0| 5| -3.147799| -1.271416| -6.914834| 2.0364e+03| +| 0| 6| -2.962716| -2.664273| -7.800357| 2.0171e+03| +| 0| 7| -4.083257| -2.080066| -8.553973| 2.0155e+03| +| 0| 8| -4.522566| -4.400710| -11.005428| 2.0149e+03| +| 0| 9| -7.252524| -5.240218| -14.876499| 2.0149e+03| +| 0| 10| -10.834476| -10.711888| -23.634504| 2.0149e+03| +----------------------------------------------------------------+ | Multizone Summary | +----------------------------------------------------------------+ | Outer_Iter| avg[bgs][0]| avg[bgs][1]|MinVolume[0]|DeformIter[0| +----------------------------------------------------------------+ -| 0| -0.298306| -2.057930| 8.8212e-10| 0| - +| 0| -0.298306| -2.048554| 8.8212e-10| 0| ... +----------------------------------------------------------------+ @@ -395,25 +387,25 @@ in ```config_channel.cfg``` to limit the printout to every 10 iterations. The re +----------------------------------------------------------------+ | Outer_Iter| Inner_Iter| rms[P]| rms[U]| rms[V]| +----------------------------------------------------------------+ -| 23| 0| -16.031295| -15.634452| -15.943223| -| 23| 10| -16.975566| -16.340396| -17.434490| +| 16| 0| -15.808168| -15.358431| -15.769282| +| 16| 10| -16.714759| -16.074145| -17.174991| +-----------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | Zone 1 (Structure) | +-----------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | Outer_Iter| Inner_Iter| rms[U]| rms[R]| rms[E]| VonMises| +-----------------------------------------------------------------------------+ -| 23| 0| -11.932854| -11.641052| -26.043863| 1.7015e+03| -| 23| 1| -15.380609| -11.613595| -28.521836| 1.7015e+03| -| 23| 2| -15.998092| -11.631016| -28.517418| 1.7015e+03| -| 23| 3| -15.999487| -11.665152| -28.602409| 1.7015e+03| -| 23| 4| -15.833821| -11.653692| -28.591287| 1.7015e+03| -| 23| 5| -15.421288| -11.637929| -28.570815| 1.7015e+03| +| 16| 0| -11.937375| -11.637725| -25.999458| 1.8531e+03| +| 16| 1| -15.794016| -11.636749| -28.541279| 1.8531e+03| +| 16| 2| -16.165350| -11.621837| -28.528692| 1.8531e+03| +| 16| 3| -16.056047| -11.608302| -28.544055| 1.8531e+03| +| 16| 4| -16.156344| -11.627675| -28.565975| 1.8531e+03| +| 16| 5| -16.204699| -11.633976| -28.581277| 1.8531e+03| +----------------------------------------------------------------+ | Multizone Summary | +----------------------------------------------------------------+ | Outer_Iter| avg[bgs][0]| avg[bgs][1]|MinVolume[0]|DeformIter[0| +----------------------------------------------------------------+ -| 23| -11.422397| -9.137915| 8.7498e-10| 44| +| 16| -11.228939| -9.130581| 8.7338e-10| 44| ``` where it can be observed that the multizone summary corresponds to the non-relaxed case presented first, and each of the subproblems are converged to a very high accuracy level. diff --git a/_tutorials/multiphysics/images/fsi2.png b/_tutorials/multiphysics/images/fsi2.png index 23d611e5..b764fdd6 100644 Binary files a/_tutorials/multiphysics/images/fsi2.png and b/_tutorials/multiphysics/images/fsi2.png differ diff --git a/_tutorials/multiphysics/images/fsi3.png b/_tutorials/multiphysics/images/fsi3.png index 0f86dbb2..50d9ad47 100644 Binary files a/_tutorials/multiphysics/images/fsi3.png and b/_tutorials/multiphysics/images/fsi3.png differ