AdaWorldAPI · AdaWorldAPI · Jul 23, 2026 · Jul 23, 2026 · Jul 23, 2026
diff --git a/.claude/board/AGENT_LOG.md b/.claude/board/AGENT_LOG.md
@@ -1,3 +1,11 @@
+## 2026-07-23 — D-DIA-V1 SHIPPED + 2 Codex-fix PRs + SoC ruling (PRs #814/#815/#816 all merged) — main thread, sole board writer
+
+- **Codex on merged #813 (PRs #814):** `deepnsm-v2::belief::close_transitive` had two P2s — (1) duplicate derivations `continue`-skipped instead of CHOICE (insertion-order-dependent truth, violating S2); (2) grounding guard keyed on `rung==0` missed derived-then-observed beliefs. Fixed by collecting max-`expectation()` per statement + keying the guard on the STAMP (evidence provenance), both with regression tests. `E-DIALECTIC-CLOSURE-CHOICE-ORDER-INDEPENDENCE-1`.
+- **Operator SoC ruling (PR #815):** was building the 5 tactics INSIDE `deepnsm-v2` reimplementing the NAL truth fns. Corrected: `deepnsm-v2` = the INBOUND leg (forward encode → belief stream); the REASONING (arena + tactics) = the lance-graph reasoning layer, reusing the ONE engine. Confirmed in code (`planner nars/{inference,truth}` already carry it). Parked the wrong `tactics.rs` to scratchpad; `E-DEEPNSM-V2-IS-INBOUND-LEG-REASONING-LIVES-IN-LANCE-GRAPH-1`.
+- **D-DIA-V1 (PR #816):** built the 5 tactics in `lance-graph-planner/src/nars/{belief,tactics}.rs` over `TruthValue`. RCR=abduction, TR=analogy (added `TruthValue::analogy` — extend the one engine), CAS up=induction/down=deduction, ASC=disjoint-stamp self-critique, CR=dialectic revision. S5 throttle (c_min/budget/hub-exclusion) + `ReasoningGap` first-class. Pinned to `contract::recipe_dispatch` via `tactic_matches_recipe_taxonomy`. The V0 arena migrated + re-expressed (dedup owed, `TD-DEEPNSM-V2-BELIEF-DUP`).
+- **Codex P2s on #816 (all fixed pre-merge + regression tests):** (1) empty incoming `Stamp::default()` defeated no-double-count → route empty stamps through CHOICE not revision; (2) CAS-up induction premise order emitted `G→P` but computed the reverse conclusion's truth → `t_sg.induction(&b.truth)`; (3) RCR budget non-deterministic under HashMap iteration → sort predicates. + CodeRabbit board-hygiene (Evidence-cell rewrite → Status-only). 17 nars + 233 planner tests + clippy clean.
+- **Outcome:** V0-V1 shipped; the dialectic reasoning is now a real, tested capability of the lance-graph reasoning layer on the one engine. Next: D-DIA-V2 (the loop — insight/mush S10 + null falsifier, GraphBias→recipe tactic-LUT).
+
 ## 2026-07-23 — D-DIA-V0 SHIPPED via a REAL dialectic loop (3 theses ∥ → 2 critics ∥ → synthesis → falsifying slice green) — main thread, sole board writer
 
 - **Task:** operator arc: "use AGI-level reasoning loops — you have the substrate"; six pillars dictated live (34-tactics-as-logic, 64k SIMT field, Staunen↔Wisdom flow, entropy×MUL dissolution, field rung-elevation cathedral, constitutive qualia). Corrections en route: NARS=logic-not-popcount (wrong rcr.rs deleted); build INSIDE not outside (rig CompletionModel plan retracted); the substrate (not the session) is the thinker.

diff --git a/.claude/board/LATEST_STATE.md b/.claude/board/LATEST_STATE.md
@@ -1,3 +1,11 @@
+## 2026-07-23 — branch `claude/x265-x266-plans-review-h9osnl` (PRs #814/#815/#816, MERGED) — the dialectic engine's REASONING LAYER: the five NARS tactics in `lance-graph-planner/src/nars` over the one engine
+
+### Current Contract Inventory — new planner reasoning modules
+- `lance_graph_planner::nars::belief::{BeliefArena, Belief, CStmt, Copula, Stamp, ReviseOutcome}` — the statement-keyed dialectic Belief arena over `TruthValue` (S2 triple-keyed dedup + CHOICE-on-`expectation()`; S3 copula-gated `close_transitive` (only Inh/Sim transit); S4 stamped `observe`/`revise_at` — disjoint→revision, overlap OR empty-stamp→CHOICE; `admit_derived` the shared throttled-frontier path, observation-ground guard keys on the STAMP).
+- `lance_graph_planner::nars::tactics::{rcr_abduce, tr_diverge, cas_abstract, asc_challenge, cr_synthesize, Candidate, ReasoningGap, GapKind, Throttle, Frontier, Tactic, AscOutcome, challenge_target}` — the FIVE tactics as term logic over the one engine (RCR=abduction, TR=analogy, CAS up=induction/down=deduction, ASC=disjoint-stamp self-critique, CR=dialectic revision); S5 throttle (c_min/budget/hub-exclusion, sorted-deterministic); pinned to `contract::recipe_dispatch` (RCR=4/TR=6/ASC=7/CAS=8/CR=11).
+- `lance_graph_planner::nars::truth::TruthValue::analogy` — the missing NAL analogy truth (`f=f·f_sim, c=c·c_sim·f_sim`), added by extending the one engine (never a local reimpl).
+- **Ruling (`E-DEEPNSM-V2-IS-INBOUND-LEG-REASONING-LIVES-IN-LANCE-GRAPH-1`):** the dialectic reasoning lives HERE (lance-graph reasoning layer); `deepnsm-v2` is the INBOUND leg (forward encode → belief stream), never a reasoning home. The V0 `deepnsm-v2/belief.rs` arena is superseded — dedup owed (`TD-DEEPNSM-V2-BELIEF-DUP`). 17 nars + 233 planner tests, clippy `-D warnings` clean. Detail: `AGENT_LOG` 2026-07-23; `PR_ARC_INVENTORY` #814/#815/#816.
+
 ## 2026-07-22 — branch `claude/x265-x266-plans-review-h9osnl` — trained Cam96 codebook SHIPPED (`deepnsm-v2/data/` + `codebook` loader) + the whole-book Bible falsifier runs ALL-GATES-GREEN (63.3% of context beyond ±5)
 
 ### Current Contract Inventory — new entries

diff --git a/.claude/board/PR_ARC_INVENTORY.md b/.claude/board/PR_ARC_INVENTORY.md
@@ -33,6 +33,17 @@
 > - **Docs** — knowledge files produced (immutable)
 > - **Confidence (YYYY-MM-DD):** — the ONLY mutable field
 
+## 2026-07-23 — lance-graph #814 / #815 / #816 — the dialectic engine's reasoning layer (D-DIA-V0 fixes + SoC ruling + D-DIA-V1 the five NARS tactics)
+
+**Merged:** #814 (`c0debe4`..`8e3024a`/`4a63777`/`f2efdf4`, squashed), #815 (`6144d48`, squashed), #816 (`08479ad`, squashed). All on `main`.
+
+- **Added (#816, code)** — `lance-graph-planner/src/nars/belief.rs` (the statement-keyed `BeliefArena`: `Belief`/`CStmt`/`Copula`/`Stamp`/`ReviseOutcome`, `observe`/`revise_at`/`admit_derived`/`close_transitive`, all over `TruthValue`) + `nars/tactics.rs` (the five tactics `rcr_abduce`/`tr_diverge`/`cas_abstract`/`asc_challenge`/`cr_synthesize`, `Candidate`/`ReasoningGap`/`GapKind`/`Throttle`/`Frontier`/`Tactic`) + `TruthValue::analogy` (the missing NAL function). Re-exported from `nars/mod.rs`. 17 nars + 233 planner tests.
+- **Added (#814)** — the Codex-fixed `close_transitive` (CHOICE-on-`expectation()` dedup + stamp-based observation guard) on the V0 `deepnsm-v2/belief.rs` arena.
+- **Locked** — **the dialectic reasoning lives in the lance-graph reasoning layer (lance-graph-planner `nars/`), on the ONE engine (`TruthValue`/`NarsInference`)** — NEVER a local truth-function reimpl (`E-DEEPNSM-V2-IS-INBOUND-LEG-REASONING-LIVES-IN-LANCE-GRAPH-1`, #815). `deepnsm-v2` = the INBOUND leg (forward encode → belief stream), NOT a reasoning home. Tactics pinned to `contract::recipe_dispatch` (RCR=4/TR=6/ASC=7/CAS=8/CR=11) via `tactic_matches_recipe_taxonomy`. S2 dedup keys on max-`expectation()` (order-independent); the observation-ground guard keys on the STAMP (evidence provenance), never the rung. Empty incoming stamps route through CHOICE (never pool). RCR predicate iteration is sorted (deterministic under budget).
+- **Deferred** — `deepnsm-v2/belief.rs` V0 arena dedup (`TD-DEEPNSM-V2-BELIEF-DUP`; repoint deepnsm-v2 to emit the belief stream only). D-DIA-V2 (the loop: insight/mush S10 + null falsifier, GraphBias→recipe tactic-LUT) registered in `dialectic-engine-v1.md` §4.
+- **Docs** — `dialectic-engine-v1.md` (§3 tactics, §4 build order, V1 home corrected); EPIPHANIES `E-DIALECTIC-CLOSURE-CHOICE-ORDER-INDEPENDENCE-1` + `E-DEEPNSM-V2-IS-INBOUND-LEG-REASONING-LIVES-IN-LANCE-GRAPH-1` + `E-DIALECTIC-V1-TACTICS-IN-PLANNER-1`.
+- **Confidence (2026-07-23):** working — V0-V1 shipped, all gates green; SIMT lowering (S1) and eager-vs-frontier admission at scale are V4, unbuilt.
+
 ## 2026-07-21 — lance-graph #793 — anti-pattern-matching PreToolUse guard (tooling); a MarkovBundler deletion mistake caught + fully reverted
 
 **Merged:** `52073cb2` (content `2e21a8e8`). `.claude/` tooling only — no source/contract change.

diff --git a/.claude/board/STATUS_BOARD.md b/.claude/board/STATUS_BOARD.md
@@ -1,11 +1,11 @@
 ## dialectic-engine-v1 — the reasoning cathedral (ACTIVE)
 
-Plan: `.claude/plans/dialectic-engine-v1.md` (six operator pillars + S1-S12 synthesis). V0 SHIPPED; V1-V5 queued.
+Plan: `.claude/plans/dialectic-engine-v1.md` (six operator pillars + S1-S12 synthesis). V0-V1 SHIPPED; V2-V5 queued.
 
 | D-id | Deliverable | Repo | Status | Evidence |
 |---|---|---|---|---|
 | D-DIA-V0 | Belief arena falsifying slice (triple-keyed + in-place stamped revision + copula-gated transitivity) | lance-graph | Shipped (all 4 registered gates green first run) | `deepnsm-v2/src/belief.rs`; 90 tests + clippy clean; `E-DIALECTIC-ENGINE-SYNTHESIS-1` |
-| D-DIA-V1 | The five tactics (RCR/TR/ASC/CAS/CR) over the Belief arena + throttles + ReasoningGap | lance-graph | In PR | plan §3, §4 |
+| D-DIA-V1 | The five tactics (RCR/TR/ASC/CAS/CR) over the Belief arena + throttles + ReasoningGap | lance-graph | Shipped (PR #816; lance-graph-planner `nars/{belief,tactics}` over `TruthValue`; 17 nars + 233 planner tests) | plan §3, §4 |
 | D-DIA-V2 | The loop: bias→recipe LUT, byte-lane council, texture window, insight/mush + null falsifier | lance-graph | Queued | plan §4 |
 | D-DIA-V3 | Dissolution → field rung-elevation (the cathedral floors) + Staunen↔Wisdom flow accounting | lance-graph | Queued | plan §4 |
 | D-DIA-V4 | 64k SIMT lowering (Boolean-reachability semiring + second-pass truth) | lance-graph | Queued | plan §4, S1 |

diff --git a/.claude/plans/dialectic-engine-v1.md b/.claude/plans/dialectic-engine-v1.md
@@ -163,6 +163,22 @@ stamps) and felt form (Datapath, texture) are one event read from two buckets.
   > planner tests green. V0 `deepnsm-v2/belief.rs` dedup owed (`TD-DEEPNSM-V2-BELIEF-DUP`).
 - **V2:** the loop — GraphBias→recipe LUT, byte-lane council, texture window,
   insight/mush (S10) + its null falsifier, kanban wiring.
+  > **NEXT SLICE (register-before-code, 2026-07-23):** build V2-A in
+  > `lance-graph-planner/src/nars` FIRST — the S10 insight/mush detector as a
+  > PURE scored function over before/after `BeliefArena` signals
+  > (`INSIGHT = clamp(Δcoh+Δwonder−Δent,0,1)·[yield>θ]`;
+  > `MUSH = 0.5·churn+0.5·stall`, `churn = revision_velocity·(1−yield)`,
+  > `stall = entropy·(1−|Δcoh|)`) WITH its MANDATORY size-preserving null
+  > falsifier (E-BASIN-WIDTH: the discriminator must beat a shuffle/
+  > size-preserving control before "detects insight" is promoted). Signals
+  > read from the arena (yield = derived/premise rate, coherence = mean
+  > expectation, entropy = truth spread, revision_velocity = revisions/step,
+  > wonder from contradiction depth). THEN V2-B: the S8 GraphBias→recipe-LUT
+  > tactic selection (which of the 5 fires inside CognitiveWork — distinct
+  > from `advance_on_gate` PHASE movement). Consult `GraphSignals` (contract
+  > exploration), `FlowState`/`mul`, `kanban` (contract + planner
+  > style_strategy) before wiring. Reuse the one engine; probe-first on any
+  > "detects insight" claim.
 - **V3:** dissolution detection + field elevation (S11) — the cathedral floors;
   Staunen↔Wisdom flow accounting; epiphany attractors (rate-normalized, S9).
 - **V4:** the 64k SIMT lowering — Boolean-reachability semiring + truth second