AdaWorldAPI · AdaWorldAPI · Jul 23, 2026 · Jul 23, 2026
diff --git a/.claude/board/AGENT_LOG.md b/.claude/board/AGENT_LOG.md
@@ -1,3 +1,11 @@
+## 2026-07-23 — D-DIA-S9 epiphany attractors (rank by rate) — 1 Sonnet grindwork agent from an Opus spec, Opus-gated (sole board writer)
+
+- **Operator steer:** answered the D-SCI-1-vs-remainders AskUserQuestion with "small dialectic remainders" (+ Gutenberg science text for D-SCI-1's future corpus, + the arXiv-ephemeral-via-tesseract/spider option). This is the S9 remainder. Build was grindwork (design = the density-ranking primitive + the rate-vs-count divergence falsifier) → one `general-purpose·sonnet` (edit-only; tag `exec-runs/dia-s9-epiphany.txt`).
+- **Deliverable:** `nars/epiphany.rs` (`rank_epiphany_attractors` + `EpiphanyAttractor`) — rank subject-basins by density (`derived/total`) not count, the E-DOOMSCROLL discipline (S9). `E-DIA-S9-EPIPHANY-ATTRACTOR-RATE-1`. Completes D-DIA-V3.
+- **⚠ Central gate caught a Sonnet regression:** the agent, inserting the `epiphany` re-export alphabetically into `nars/mod.rs`, DROPPED the `reach_out` re-export line (module still declared, public items no longer re-exported). Orchestrator restored `pub use reach_out::{reach_out_integrate, FeltOutcome, ReachOutConfig};` before gating — a concrete instance of why the fleet edits and the orchestrator compiles/gates centrally (the edit-only agent can't see the compile regression its own alphabetical edit caused).
+- **Falsifier finding (banked):** rate-ranking surfaces a small dense basin (rate 0.75, count 3) that count-ranking buries under a large sparse one (rate 0.20, count 5) — the orderings diverge, which is the E-DOOMSCROLL point.
+- **Orchestrator-verified:** 3 epiphany tests + 47 nars-module tests green (the 47 confirms the reach_out re-export restore compiles); `cargo fmt` + `cargo clippy -p lance-graph-planner --lib -- -D warnings` clean; `Cargo.lock` restored.
+
 ## 2026-07-23 — D-DIA-V5-A reach-out felt integration (§3.6) — 1 Sonnet grindwork agent from an Opus spec, Opus-gated (sole board writer)
 
 - **Operator directive:** "use sonnet agents for grindwork." The §3.6 criterion reduces to a structural test (middle-term click = a derivation lands), so the design (quarantine + new-derivation gate + the size-matched falsifier) was worked on the main thread and the build was grindwork → one `general-purpose·sonnet` (edit-only, no cargo/worktree; tag `exec-runs/dia-v5a-reach-out.txt`).

diff --git a/.claude/board/EPIPHANIES.md b/.claude/board/EPIPHANIES.md
@@ -1,3 +1,11 @@
+## 2026-07-23 — E-DIA-S9-EPIPHANY-ATTRACTOR-RATE-1 — epiphany attractors rank basins by DENSITY (derived/total closure rate per subject), never raw count — the E-DOOMSCROLL "rank by rate, never count" discipline (S9, third confirmation) applied to epiphany sites, so the field never collapses into its largest basin.
+
+**Status:** SHIPPED (`nars/epiphany.rs`, Sonnet-built from an Opus spec, Opus-gated; 3 tests green, 47 nars-module tests, clippy `-D warnings` + fmt clean). **Confidence:** High — a size-normalized ranking primitive over the shipped closure-density notion; the discipline itself is thrice-confirmed (E-DOOMSCROLL).
+
+**What it is.** D-DIA-S9. `rank_epiphany_attractors(&arena, min_attempts) -> Vec<EpiphanyAttractor{subject, epiphanies, attempts, rate}>` groups beliefs by subject, computes each basin's epiphany density (`derived ÷ total`, a `rung>=1` belief proxying a landed epiphany at that subject — the same closure-density notion `nars::insight` uses globally), and ranks by RATE desc (ties → subject id asc, deterministic). The `min_attempts` floor drops thin basins.
+
+**The finding (why rate, not count).** The falsifier `rate_ranking_beats_count_ranking` builds a LARGE sparse basin (subject 1: 20 obs + 5 derived → rate 0.20, raw count 5) and a SMALL dense basin (subject 2: 1 obs + 3 derived → rate 0.75, raw count 3). Rate-ranking surfaces subject 2 (#1); count-ranking surfaces subject 1 (#1) — the two orderings **diverge**, and the divergence IS the point: a count-ranked field collapses into whichever basin is biggest (it accrues raw epiphany-count merely by size), burying the genuinely dense attractor. Size-normalization is the fix. This is the third confirmation of E-DOOMSCROLL — the same rate-not-count discipline that governs thought promotion/prune and WisdomMarker neighborhood bias, now on epiphany sites. Cross-ref: `nars::insight` (closure density, global), plan §1 S9 + §4 V3 (epiphany attractors), E-DOOMSCROLL.
+
 ## 2026-07-23 — E-DIA-V5-A-FELT-INTEGRATION-1 — the §3.6 "dull shadow vs new insight" felt criterion is ONE structural test read two ways: fetched external material integrates IFF it serves as the middle term composing pre-existing disjoint-stamp beliefs (a derivation lands, coherence rises = insight); otherwise nothing moves (dull shadow). The felt form and the audit form are the same event — no separate qualia service.
 
 **Status:** SHIPPED (`nars/reach_out.rs`, Sonnet-built from an Opus spec, Opus-gated; 4 tests green, 255 planner-lib tests, clippy `-D warnings` + fmt clean). **Confidence:** High on the structural criterion + the quarantine; the S12 qualia-ablation *field-scale* falsifier (doomscroll cycles, Staunen→Wisdom conversion) is a later V5 slice.

diff --git a/.claude/board/STATUS_BOARD.md b/.claude/board/STATUS_BOARD.md
@@ -8,7 +8,7 @@ Plan: `.claude/plans/dialectic-engine-v1.md` (six operator pillars + S1-S12 synt
 | D-DIA-V1 | The five tactics (RCR/TR/ASC/CAS/CR) over the Belief arena + throttles + ReasoningGap | lance-graph | Shipped (PR #816; lance-graph-planner `nars/{belief,tactics}` over `TruthValue`; 17 nars + 233 planner tests) | plan §3, §4 |
 | D-DIA-V2-A | insight/mush S10 detector + size-preserving null falsifier | lance-graph | Shipped (PR #819 merged; `nars/insight.rs`; null falsifier caught + fixed 2 formula confounds — `E-S10-COHERENCE-CLOSURE-DENSITY-1`) | plan §1 S10, §4 |
 | D-DIA-V2-B | The loop: bias→recipe tactic-LUT, byte-lane council, texture window | lance-graph | **bias→tactic LUT SHIPPED** (`E-DIA-V2-B-BIAS-TACTIC-LUT-1`; `nars/tactic_select.rs` `tactic_for_bias`/`TacticChoice` reusing `contract::sensorium::GraphBias`; confusion-matrix falsifier `examples/tactic_select_confusion.rs` — G1 5/5 diagonal, G2 3/3 structural discrimination, G3 beats constant policy; honest split: RCR/TR/CAS structural, ASC/CR normative; 4 unit + 28 nars tests, clippy clean). Byte-lane i8 council + texture window still queued. | plan §1 S8, §4 |
-| D-DIA-V3 | Dissolution → field rung-elevation (the cathedral floors) + Staunen↔Wisdom flow accounting | lance-graph | **V3-A + V3-B + V3-C SHIPPED (the S11 loop is CLOSED).** V3-A detector (`E-DIA-V3-A-DISSOLUTION-DETECTOR-1`; `nars/dissolution.rs`, S10 mirror on `insight::Snapshot`; null PASS). V3-B response (`E-DIA-V3-B-FIELD-ELEVATION-1`; `nars/elevation.rs` `elevate_field` — mass-induction mints abstract parents over shared-predicate clusters, HHTL grows upward; falsifier proves the PAYOFF = one parent-fact propagates to all k children via closure, and the honest guard = nothing minted on structureless noise; 3 tests). V3-C `regulate_cycle` (`nars/regulate.rs`) composes detect_dissolution→should_elevate→elevate_field into one active-inference cycle (`E-DIA-V3-C-REGULATION-LOOP-1`; elevation TRIGGERED by measurement not chosen; 3 tests — dissolving→elevates, crystallizing→no-op, loop bounded across cycles). Remaining V3: epiphany attractors (S9). | plan §0 pillars 3-5, §1 S11, §4 |
+| D-DIA-V3 | Dissolution → field rung-elevation (the cathedral floors) + Staunen↔Wisdom flow accounting | lance-graph | **V3-A + V3-B + V3-C SHIPPED (the S11 loop is CLOSED).** V3-A detector (`E-DIA-V3-A-DISSOLUTION-DETECTOR-1`; `nars/dissolution.rs`, S10 mirror on `insight::Snapshot`; null PASS). V3-B response (`E-DIA-V3-B-FIELD-ELEVATION-1`; `nars/elevation.rs` `elevate_field` — mass-induction mints abstract parents over shared-predicate clusters, HHTL grows upward; falsifier proves the PAYOFF = one parent-fact propagates to all k children via closure, and the honest guard = nothing minted on structureless noise; 3 tests). V3-C `regulate_cycle` (`nars/regulate.rs`) composes detect_dissolution→should_elevate→elevate_field into one active-inference cycle (`E-DIA-V3-C-REGULATION-LOOP-1`; elevation TRIGGERED by measurement not chosen; 3 tests — dissolving→elevates, crystallizing→no-op, loop bounded across cycles). **S9 epiphany attractors SHIPPED** (`E-DIA-S9-EPIPHANY-ATTRACTOR-RATE-1`; `nars/epiphany.rs` `rank_epiphany_attractors` — rank basins by density not count, E-DOOMSCROLL 3rd confirmation; 3 tests, rate-vs-count divergence falsifier). V3 fully shipped. | plan §0 pillars 3-5, §1 S11, §4 |
 | D-DIA-V4 | Foveated HHTL-trie field-search (addressing-first ladder; field search = total-function floor). Rung 1 = `PROBE-CODEBOOK-44` (16-way hierarchical codebook), rung 2 = foveated morton-comma descent, rung 3 = `PremultipliedOver` blasgraph `mxv` floor. Kuzu factorized-processing alignment. | lance-graph + bgz17 | Rung 1 MECHANISM-GREEN + REAL-DATA ρ RUN (`E-PROBE-CODEBOOK-44-MECHANISM-1`: `bgz17::build_hierarchical`, prefix==ancestry purity 1.0 vs flat 0.16; real-data ρ on jina-v3 = hierarchy fidelity-neutral (structure-is-free confirmed), but anchor-close blocked by the Base17 17-dim fold ceiling ρ=0.26 — `TD-BASE17-FOLD-CEILING-SINGLE-WORD`, NOT the codebook; M1 not fully closed). **Rungs 2-3 + M26 SHIPPED** (`E-DIA-V4-FIELD-SEARCH-LOOP-1`, 4-agent Sonnet fleet, Opus-gated): rung 2 `foveated_descend` (8× prune + full recall at fovea_k=2), rung 3 `premultiplied_over` commutative composite (bgz17 palette, not blasgraph), M26 `Belief⟷SpoFacet` lossless byte round-trip. #4 CV-sweep refined `TD-BASE17-FOLD-CEILING`. Architecture `E-FOVEATED-HHTL-TRIE-FIELD-SEARCH-1` | plan §4, S1 |
 | D-DIA-V5 | Reach-out felt integration (dull shadow vs insight) + qualia ablation falsifier | lance-graph | **V5-A SHIPPED** (`E-DIA-V5-A-FELT-INTEGRATION-1`; `nars/reach_out.rs` `reach_out_integrate`/`FeltOutcome` — the §3.6 middle-term-click criterion as a structural test: fetched bridge quarantined at prior 0.1, NewInsight iff ≥1 derivation composed vs DullShadow; 4 tests incl. size-matched + quarantine-cap). Remaining V5: the S12 qualia-ablation FIELD-scale falsifier. | plan §3.6, S12 |
 

diff --git a/.claude/board/exec-runs/dia-s9-epiphany.txt b/.claude/board/exec-runs/dia-s9-epiphany.txt
@@ -0,0 +1,35 @@
+Task: D-DIA-S9 — epiphany attractors ranked by rate, never count
+
+Files touched:
+- crates/lance-graph-planner/src/nars/epiphany.rs (NEW)
+- crates/lance-graph-planner/src/nars/mod.rs (EDIT: added `pub mod epiphany;`
+  in alphabetical position after `elevation` before `facet_fold`, and
+  `pub use epiphany::{rank_epiphany_attractors, EpiphanyAttractor};` re-export)
+
+Deliverable:
+- `EpiphanyAttractor { subject: u16, epiphanies: usize, attempts: usize, rate: f32 }`
+- `rank_epiphany_attractors(arena: &BeliefArena, min_attempts: usize) -> Vec<EpiphanyAttractor>`
+  groups arena entries by `stmt.s`, counts total (attempts) vs rung>=1 (epiphanies),
+  filters by min_attempts, sorts by rate DESC then subject ASC (f32::total_cmp).
+
+Tests (3, as specified):
+1. rate_ranking_beats_count_ranking — S9/E-DOOMSCROLL falsifier. Large sparse
+   basin (subject 1: 20 observed + 5 derived, rate 0.20) vs small dense basin
+   (subject 2: 1 observed + 3 derived, rate 0.75). Asserts rate-ranking top =
+   subject 2, count-ranking top = subject 1, and the two orderings diverge.
+2. min_attempts_filters_thin_basins — subject 1 (3 beliefs) survives
+   min_attempts=2, subject 2 (1 belief) is filtered out.
+3. ordering_is_deterministic_on_ties — subject 3 and subject 5 both at
+   rate 0.5; asserts tie broken by subject id ASC (3 before 5).
+
+Source verification performed (not guessed):
+- Read belief.rs: confirmed `BeliefArena::entries()`, `observe(CStmt, TruthValue,
+  Stamp) -> ReviseOutcome`, `admit_derived(CStmt, TruthValue, &[u32], u32) -> bool`,
+  `Belief { stmt, rung, .. }`, `CStmt { s, cop, p }`, `Copula::Inh`,
+  `Stamp::source(u32)` all match the spec exactly. Confirmed `BeliefArena`
+  derives `Default` (used `BeliefArena::default()` in tests; equivalent to
+  `BeliefArena::new()` used elsewhere in the file).
+- Confirmed mod.rs re-export style/alphabetical pub mod ordering before editing.
+
+Did NOT run cargo (build/check/test/clippy/fmt) per hard rules — edit-only,
+orchestrator gates centrally. No git operations performed.
diff --git a/.claude/plans/dialectic-engine-v1.md b/.claude/plans/dialectic-engine-v1.md
@@ -231,7 +231,16 @@ stamps) and felt form (Datapath, texture) are one event read from two buckets.
   > 3 tests: dissolving-step→elevates, crystallizing-step→no-op, loop bounded
   > across cycles (the V3-B idempotence is what makes a CLOSED loop safe). The
   > S11 dissolution→elevation floor is now a complete, closed, bounded, null-
-  > tested loop. Remaining V3: epiphany attractors (S9).
+  > tested loop.
+  > **✅ S9 epiphany attractors SHIPPED (2026-07-23):** `nars/epiphany.rs` —
+  > `rank_epiphany_attractors(&arena, min_attempts)` ranks subject-basins by
+  > epiphany DENSITY (`derived/total` closure rate), never raw count — the
+  > E-DOOMSCROLL "rank by rate, never count" discipline (S9, 3rd confirmation)
+  > so the field never collapses into its largest basin
+  > (`E-DIA-S9-EPIPHANY-ATTRACTOR-RATE-1`; falsifier: a small dense basin
+  > out-ranks a large sparse one on rate while count buries it — the orderings
+  > diverge). **V3 is now fully shipped** (V3-A detector + V3-B response + V3-C
+  > loop + S9 attractors).
   > **✅ V3-B (field-elevation RESPONSE) SHIPPED (2026-07-23):** `nars/elevation.rs`
   > — `elevate_field(&mut arena, min_cluster) -> Elevation`. The mass-induction
   > sweep: groups OBSERVED `is_a` subjects by shared predicate `M`, and for each