RP-SEAL pass 1 consolidated: evidence matrix, tiering, Appendix H (15 reports)

.claude/board/AGENT_LOG.md

@@ -1,3 +1,19 @@
+## 2026-08-19 — RP-SEAL first pass: 15 researchers (5 domains × builder/adversary/scout; orchestrator-consolidated)
+
+15/15 completed, 0 errors, 0 empty results (~5.59M subagent tokens, 842 tool
+uses, run `wf_ca974718-1b4`). Adversary cells Opus, builder/scout Sonnet, per
+the model-policy split. First pass fully independent: no cross-talk, blind to
+`docs/lotus/**` and all board files; every brief carried the no-cargo +
+tag-file-only rules — 0 cargo invocations measured across all transcripts;
+this entry is the orchestrator consolidating, per the one-writer rule.
+Mid-run operator scope pivot (rustynum struck / symbiont deprecated) applied
+as a consolidation hard filter: audit found zero findings sourced from
+either; nothing re-run. One agent death (A3, permission denial on the
+sandboxed workflow driver) self-healed on resume with full cache reuse.
+Outcome: `docs/lotus/RP-SEAL-CONSOLIDATION-PASS1.md` (matrix M1–M15,
+cross-domain graph, DELETED list, Tier 0–4 work order) + Appendix H
+(`docs/lotus/rp-seal-v1/`, 16 reports incl. the orchestrator pre-pass).
+
 ## 2026-08-13 — weather-poc W0/W1 fleet (4 Sonnet workers, disjoint files; orchestrator-consolidated)
 
 4/4 completed, 0 errors. Plan `.claude/plans/weather-soa-bake-v1.md`; the first

.claude/board/EPIPHANIES.md

@@ -1,3 +1,85 @@
+## 2026-08-19 — E-REPLAY-IS-CANONICAL-COMPACTION-IS-ECONOMICS-1
+
+**Status:** RULING `[operator]` (STORNO of pass-1 consolidation framing).
+
+**STORNO'd:** the RP-SEAL consolidation's framing that physical-layout
+work gates the cognitive/meta arc. Compaction is NOT required for the
+target architecture. The D2 defect, restated narrower and more serious:
+**PHYSICAL ITERATION ORDER MUST NOT DEFINE SEMANTIC REPLAY ORDER.** Fix
+by canonical replay coordinates/order — never by physical reordering or
+compaction. Separately: permanent temporal replay requires a
+retention/tombstone policy under which historical knowledge states
+remain reconstructible indefinitely.
+
+**The desired model (verbatim):** physical placement may remain
+arbitrary · physical fragmentation may remain arbitrary · tombstoned
+state remains historically addressable · semantic replay order is
+canonical · current visibility is a projection · historical visibility
+is a QueryReference projection. Compaction, if ever enabled, is only
+optional storage economics — neither semantic repair nor a prerequisite
+for cognition.
+
+**Applied:** consolidation doc §0 (`docs/lotus/RP-SEAL-CONSOLIDATION-
+PASS1.md`) with ⊘-marked in-place corrections; Tier 1 reordered
+(canonical coordinates №1, retention/tombstone №2, QueryReference
+projection fixes №3); all layout/compaction items reclassified optional
+economics; F-NOCOMPACT promoted from soak test to the default operating
+description. Corrects the gating framing in
+`E-RP-SEAL-PASS1-THE-MAXIM-WORKED-1` (its findings stand; their
+consequence inverts — M2/M12 are reasons compaction stays off).
+
+## 2026-08-19 — E-RP-SEAL-PASS1-THE-MAXIM-WORKED-1
+
+**Status:** FINDING (consolidated), first independent pass complete.
+
+**The event.** The RP-SEAL 15-researcher independent pass (run
+`wf_ca974718-1b4`, 15/15 cells, 0 errors, no cross-talk, blind to boards)
+completed and was consolidated per charter §12–§13:
+`docs/lotus/RP-SEAL-CONSOLIDATION-PASS1.md`, with all 15 reports + the
+orchestrator pre-pass committed as Appendix H under `docs/lotus/rp-seal-v1/`.
+
+**What died (charter §17 executed):** the phase/comma coefficient schedule
+(C2 adversary: 0/6 conditions, syndrome separation impossible under
+permutation; C1+C3 independently bound cascades ≥33% overhead / priced in
+distance — three disjoint routes, one kill); unconditional Morton/SFC
+default (B2 measured + B3 literature: identical page partition to Hilbert
+at 4^j pages, 20–45× quantizer hot-spots, three proven negative results);
+"compaction = one manifest publication" (reserve_fragment_ids is itself a
+commit); the naive query+repair one-grouping hope (Morton locality
+MANUFACTURES the correlated failure that kills locality-aligned parity).
+
+**What was found:** the coalescing path writes MORE bytes than no
+coalescing — physical amplification = b+1 (65× at b=64) from 512 B null
+padding per landing row, and 52% of seal CPU is a non-amortizing FNV hash
+(E2); 11 arrival/physical-order leaks into durable coordinates, worst
+L2: durable semantic replay order IS Lance physical scan order, so
+compaction here MUTATES semantics (D2) — this gates all layout work;
+five shipped seal paths with defective/false-accept behavior wearing
+strong names (C2 §B1–B5, firefly independently by C3); Lance 9.0.0
+already ships the whole compaction/remap/stable-row-id/per-row-version
+apparatus unused by our append-only path (5 cells concordant).
+
+**What survived, sharpened:** boring hash + row/column P+Q over the native
+64×64 (6.25%, 63× repair amplification vs flat-RS 4095×) as the seal
+baseline; the caller-supplied compaction-rewrite ordering key as the ONE
+open precedented upstream seam (in-repo R-tree Hilbert leaves + Delta
+Z-order as precedent; IndexRemapper usable today); two genuine
+NOVEL-CANDIDATES with no prior art found by independent searches — the
+joint query-scatter × repair-scatter address-order question (refined by
+C2's anti-synergy into "query-aligned order, ANTI-aligned parity groups")
+and the STRICT/AWARE/RETRO reader-rung admission tier (D3: no literature
+counterpart; D1: currently inert in code, T_now missing as a type,
+hlc_tick not actually HLC).
+
+**Scope-pivot filter:** PASSED — zero findings sourced from rustynum or
+symbiont; the two mentions cite the exclusion ruling, and D1 converts it
+into a finding (the version→kanban OUT-bridge lost its only caller).
+
+**Tier 0 before anything else:** pin D2's leaks (F-PHYS-ORDER first),
+re-verify E2, X-C2-1 injection harness over the five seal paths, E3's
+locality-debt trigger metric, perf-event or strike the cache-miss metric.
+Full matrix M1–M15 + tiering in the consolidation doc.
+
 ## 2026-08-18 — E-PIN-LANCE9-LANCEDB033-DF541-ARROW58-NO-DF53-1
 
 **Status:** RULING `[operator]` + same-day discharge, measured.

.claude/board/STATUS_BOARD.md

@@ -1,4 +1,4 @@
-## erasure-seals-compaction-research-v1 — RP-SEAL (operator charter, DISPATCHED 2026-08-18)
+## erasure-seals-compaction-research-v1 — RP-SEAL (operator charter; PASS 1 CONSOLIDATED 2026-08-19 + §0 STORNO: canonical replay coordinates core, compaction = optional economics → docs/lotus/RP-SEAL-CONSOLIDATION-PASS1.md; Tier 0 probes next)
 
 Plan: `.claude/plans/erasure-seals-compaction-research-v1.md` (the operator's
 15-researcher program; supersedes lotus deliverables 3-9's sequencing).

.claude/plans/erasure-seals-compaction-research-v1.md

@@ -3,6 +3,16 @@
 > **Status: DISPATCHED 2026-08-18** — independent pass running as a 15-agent
 > background workflow (run `wf_ca974718-1b4`; reports land under the session
 > scratchpad `rp-seal-v1/`, committed at consolidation as Appendix H).
+>
+> **PASS 1 COMPLETE + CONSOLIDATED (2026-08-19).** 15/15 cells, 0 errors.
+> Consolidation: `docs/lotus/RP-SEAL-CONSOLIDATION-PASS1.md` (M1–M15,
+> DELETED list, Tier 0–4). Appendix H committed: `docs/lotus/rp-seal-v1/`.
+> The comma schedule is DELETED per §17; Tier 0 probes are the next phase.
+> **§0 STORNO (operator, same day):** canonical replay coordinates are
+> the core fix (physical iteration order must not define semantic replay
+> order); retention/tombstone for indefinite historical reconstructibility
+> is core; compaction = optional storage economics, never semantic repair,
+> never a cognition prerequisite. See the consolidation doc §0.
 > Tier allocation per the operator's "Opus for filigrane, Sonnet for
 > grindwork": the five ADVERSARY cells (A2/B2/C2/D2/E2) = strongest tier;
 > the five BUILDER and five SCOUT cells = grindwork tier. Consolidation