[Outcome Report] Outcome Report — 2026-05-22

[github-actions]

Outcome Scorecard — 2026-05-22

Metric	Value	Status
Acceptance rate	100%	🟢 >80%
Zero-touch rate	0%	🔴 <25%
Waste rate	0%	🟢 <10%
Median time to resolution	~5.5 hours	—
Accepted	10 / 26	—
Rejected	0	—
Zero-touch	0 / 10	—
Pending	16	—
Runs checked	11	—

🔴 Action Items

1. Workflows blocked with pending items — 5 workflows have outstanding pending outcomes:

   • PR Code Quality Reviewer: 5/5 items pending (100% — blocked since ~1.75 hours ago)
   • Matt Pocock Skills Reviewer: 4/4 items pending (100% — blocked since ~1.73 hours ago)
   • PR Sous Chef: 2/2 items pending (100% — blocked since ~1.56 hours ago)
   • Test Quality Sentinel: 1/2 pending
   • Issue Monster: 3/6 pending — but also has 3 accepted comments
   • Auto-Triage Issues: 1/2 pending

   Issue: All pending items show "no url" as detail, indicating safeoutputs calls were not created or the URLs were not captured. Root cause needs investigation.

2. Zero-touch rate is 0% — All accepted items required manual human work or had issues (e.g., url missing, object created but outcome not captured). No workflows are producing fully autonomous outcomes.

3. Stuck pending workflows — PR review workflows (PR Code Quality Reviewer, Matt Pocock Skills Reviewer) have been pending for >100 minutes with no URLs. These likely represent failed safeoutputs calls or missing GitHub references.

Per-Workflow Breakdown

Workflow Performance

Workflow	Accepted	Rejected	Pending	Acceptance	Issue
Semantic Function Refactoring	1	0	0	100%	✅ No issues
Daily Sentrux Report	1	0	0	100%	✅ No issues
Daily Reliability Review	1	0	0	100%	✅ No issues
Daily Model Inventory Checker	1	0	0	100%	✅ No issues
Daily Documentation Healer	1	0	0	100%	✅ No issues
Issue Monster	3	0	3	50%	⚠️ 3 pending with no URLs (assign_to_agent)
Test Quality Sentinel	1	0	1	50%	⚠️ 1 pending (submit_pull_request_review)
Auto-Triage Issues	1	0	1	50%	⚠️ 1 pending (add_labels) with no URL
PR Sous Chef	0	0	2	0%	🔴 All pending (update_pull_request) with no URLs
Matt Pocock Skills Reviewer	0	0	4	0%	🔴 All pending (PR review comments) with no URLs
PR Code Quality Reviewer	0	0	5	0%	🔴 All pending (PR review comments) with no URLs

Pending Item Details

16 Pending Outcomes Requiring Investigation

PR Code Quality Reviewer (5 pending, ~1.75 hrs):

• 4× create_pull_request_review_comment — no URL
• 1× submit_pull_request_review — no URL

Matt Pocock Skills Reviewer (4 pending, ~1.73 hrs):

• 3× create_pull_request_review_comment — no URL
• 1× submit_pull_request_review — no URL

PR Sous Chef (2 pending, ~1.56 hrs):

• 2× update_pull_request — no URL

Issue Monster (3 pending, ~1.53 hrs):

• 3× assign_to_agent — no URL

Test Quality Sentinel (1 pending, ~1.67 hrs):

• 1× submit_pull_request_review — no URL

Auto-Triage Issues (1 pending, ~0.10 hrs, recent):

• 1× add_labels — no URL

Root cause pattern: All pending items report "no url" as detail. This suggests:

• safeoutputs calls may be failing silently
• URLs not being returned from GitHub API responses
• Issue/PR/comment references not being captured properly
• These may be timeout/infrastructure issues that need debugging

Accepted Outcomes Summary

10 Accepted Outcomes

Issue/Discussion Creation (6 accepted):

• Daily Reliability Review: created issue [reliability] Daily Reliability Review - 2026-05-21 #33893
• Daily Documentation Healer: created issue [doc-healer] DDUw / doc-healer improvement: skip re-attempting fixes from closed-unmerged prior [docs] PRs #33899 (1 reaction)
• Semantic Function Refactoring: created issue [refactor] Semantic function clustering: dispatch/call-workflow duplicates and permission factory consolidation #33901
• Daily Model Inventory Checker: created issue [model-inventory] Model alias inventory update - 2026-05-22 #33903
• Daily Sentrux Report: created discussion [daily-sentrux] Daily Sentrux Report - 2026-05-22 #33902
• Auto-Triage Issues: created discussion [Auto-Triage] Auto-triage run 26262868032 #33904

Comments (4 accepted):

• Issue Monster: 3 accepted comments on issues [deep-report] Auto-start docs server in docs-noob-tester workflow setup #33791, [deep-report] Triage recurring Daily Issues Report Generator failures (6 / last 7 days) #33794, [testify-expert] Improve Test Quality: pkg/workflow/compiler_test.go #33837 (1 reaction each)
• Test Quality Sentinel: 1 accepted comment on PR feat: user-defined OTLP attributes with template expansion per workflow phase #33846 (merged)

Notes:

• All accepted items were created/updated without human modification
• Reactions data incomplete for most items (null values)
• All created issues/discussions remain open, no follow-up action needed

Summary

✅ Strengths:

• 100% acceptance rate for items that could be verified
• No rejections across all workflows
• Daily report workflows (Sentrux, Reliability, Documentation, etc.) operating smoothly
• Issue Monster successfully posting comments

⚠️ Concerns:

• 62% of outcomes (16/26) remain pending with "no url" — indicates systematic issue with safeoutputs capture
• 0% zero-touch rate — all accepted outcomes required manual action or have incomplete metadata
• PR review workflows completely blocked — all items pending with no URLs
• No reactions data for most accepted items — difficult to assess quality

Recommendation: Investigate why pending outcomes lack URLs. Check:

1. safeoutputs MCP server logs for errors
2. GitHub API response handling in workflow runtimes
3. URL parsing/capture in outcome evaluation logic
4. Whether pending items represent failed operations or incomplete tracking

📊 Measured by Outcome Collector · ● 29.7K

• expires on May 29, 2026, 1:37 AM UTC

[github-actions]

Outcome Scorecard — 2026-05-22

Metric	Value	Status
Acceptance rate	100%	🟢 Excellent (was 28.6% yesterday)
Zero-touch rate	0%	🟡 Low / builds on accepted
Waste rate	0%	🟢 No rejections
Median time to resolution	~1h 34m	—
Accepted	8 / 20	—
Rejected	0	—
Pending	12	—
Zero-touch	0 / 8	—
Runs checked	11	—

🟢 Key Improvements

Massive turnaround from yesterday: Acceptance rate jumped from 28.6% to 100% on completed items. The 6 scheduled workflows that completed today all succeeded. This suggests the safe-output system fixes deployed in the last cycle are working well.

🟡 Action Items

1. Pending items clearing slowly — 12 items (60% of total) are still pending. Most are from PR workflows (Chaos PR Bundle Fuzzer: 5, PR Sous Chef: 3, Contribution Check: 3, PR Description Updater: 1). These have been waiting 1.5–2 hours. Verify these workflows are still running and completing normally, or they may need manual review.

2. PR-interactive workflows show mixed results — Three workflows create or update PRs:

   • Chaos PR Bundle Fuzzer: 5 PRs created (all pending ~2h)
   • PR Sous Chef: 1 comment accepted (merged PR), 3 items pending ~2h
   • Contribution Check: 3 pending items ~1.7h

   The successful item (PR Sous Chef merge) shows these workflows can work, but pending PRs need attention.

3. Zero-touch rate at 0% — All 8 accepted items required human review/merge. This is normal for created PRs and issues (they need review), but note if this trend continues with single-item outputs.

Per-Workflow Breakdown

Workflow	Accepted	Pending	Acceptance	Notes
Daily Hippo Learn	1	0	100%	✅ Scheduled workflow, clean
Daily Safe Outputs Conformance Checker	1	0	100%	✅ Scheduled workflow, clean
Daily AgentRx Trace Optimizer	1	0	100%	✅ Scheduled workflow, clean
CLI Version Checker	1	0	100%	✅ Scheduled workflow, clean
Schema Consistency Checker	1	0	100%	✅ Scheduled workflow, clean
Daily CLI Tools Exploratory Tester	1	0	100%	✅ Scheduled workflow, clean
Static Analysis Report	1	0	100%	✅ Scheduled workflow, clean
PR Sous Chef	1	3	25%	⚠️ Merged 1 PR, 3 comments pending ~2h
Contribution Check	0	3	0%	⚠️ 3 items pending ~1.7h
PR Description Updater	0	1	0%	⚠️ 1 item pending ~1.5h
Chaos PR Bundle Fuzzer	0	5	0%	⚠️ 5 PRs created, all pending ~2h

⬆️ Trend Analysis

From previous report (2026-05-21):

• Acceptance rate: 28.6% → 100% ⬆️ +71.4pp (massive improvement)
• Zero-touch rate: 0% → 0% ➡️ Stable
• Waste rate: 0% → 0% ➡️ Stable
• Pending items: 15 → 12 ⬆️ Some clearing

Key shift: Yesterday's critical issue was "15 items pending with 'no url' detail indicating safe-output system issues." Today we have only 12 pending, and the system appears to be working correctly for scheduled workflows (6/6 = 100% acceptance for single-output workflows).

💡 Recommendations

1. Scheduled workflows: No action needed. All 6 completed workflows succeeded. Keep monitoring these.
2. PR workflows: Wait another 1–2 hours for the 12 pending items. If they don't resolve, investigate why PRs are taking longer than yesterday's ~1h34m median.
3. PR Sous Chef merge: This is a positive signal — shows the workflow can complete end-to-end successfully.
4. Next report: Compare pending items 24h from now to see if they eventually resolve or if there's a systemic blocker (e.g., rate limits, approval waiting on reviewers).

📊 Measured by Outcome Collector · ● 41.6K

• expires on May 29, 2026, 8:06 AM UTC

[github-actions]

Outcome Scorecard — 2026-05-22

Metric	Value	Status
Acceptance rate	100%	🟢 >80%
Zero-touch rate	0%	🟡 No completions without edits yet
Waste rate	0%	🟢 <10%
Median time to resolution	—	No pending items
Accepted	3 / 3	—
Rejected	0	—
Zero-touch	0 / 3	—
Pending	0	—
Runs checked	3	—

Workflow Summary

Workflow	Outcomes	Acceptance
Daily Token Consumption Report (Sentry OTel)	1	✅ Accepted
GitHub MCP Structural Analysis	1	✅ Accepted
Claude Code User Documentation Review	1	✅ Accepted

Key Observations

✅ Perfect acceptance: All 3 outcomes created today were accepted without rejection or modification.

📊 Event type: All runs were scheduled workflows, indicating reliable autonomous execution.

Recommendations

• Continue monitoring — This is a positive baseline. Track zero-touch rate growth as workflows mature.
• Expand tracking — As more workflows adopt safe-output tools, ensure consistent acceptance remains high.

📊 Measured by Outcome Collector · ● 15.4K

• expires on May 29, 2026, 1:44 PM UTC

[github-actions]

Outcome Scorecard — 2026-05-22

Metric	Value	Status
Acceptance rate	100%	🟢 >80%
Zero-touch rate	0%	🟡 0-25%
Waste rate	0%	🟢 <10%
Median time to resolution	—	—
Accepted	2 / 3	—
Rejected	0	—
Zero-touch	0 / 2	—
Pending	1	—
Runs checked	3	—

🟢 Key Highlights

• Strong acceptance rate (100%): All outcomes reviewed have been accepted with no rejections.
• No waste (0%): No rejected or ignored items — excellent workflow quality.
• Three workflows tracked across schedule and manual dispatch events.

🟡 Action Items

1. Investigate Pending PR #34091

• Workflow: Linter Miner (workflow_dispatch)
• Status: Open for ~24 minutes
• Details: 4 files changed, +308 additions, 0 review comments
• Recommendation: Review the Linter Miner PR output quality. If this is a typical workflow, consider adding automated checks or a review SLA.

2. Zero-Touch Rate is 0%

• All 2 accepted items required human review or modification.
• This suggests the agents are producing initial content that needs editorial refinement.
• Next steps: Review whether this is expected (e.g., discussions always need curation) or if agent prompts should be improved for higher accuracy.

Per-Workflow Breakdown

Workflow	Type	Status	Count	Details
Daily Code Metrics and Trend Tracking Agent	Discussion	Accepted	1	Created #34094
Copilot Agent PR Analysis	Discussion	Accepted	1	Created #34089
Linter Miner	Pull Request	Pending	1	PR #34091, 4 files, +308 additions

📈 Trend Signal

Comparing to previous report (2026-05-21):

• Acceptance rate: 100% → 100% (➡️ Stable)
• Zero-touch rate: 0% → 0% (➡️ Stable)
• Pending items: 2 → 1 (⬆️ Improving — one item resolved)
• Total outcomes: 4 → 3 (Fewer runs in period)

Trend: All key metrics stable. Slight improvement in pending backlog resolution.

Artifacts and References

• Summary data: /tmp/gh-aw/outcome-summary.json
• Per-run details: /tmp/gh-aw/outcomes/run-*.json
• Evaluation log: /tmp/gh-aw/outcome-evaluations.jsonl
• Previous metrics: Cached for next report cycle

📊 Measured by Outcome Collector · ● 22K

• expires on May 29, 2026, 7:27 PM UTC

[github-actions]

This issue is being closed as outdated. A newer issue has been created: #34151

View newer issue

---

This action was performed automatically by the Outcome Collector workflow.