Skip to content

Shipped README: dead links, stale claims, and gaps found by install-only acceptance testing #369

Description

@irparent

Acceptance testing of the packed tarball from a clean install (no repo checkout) surfaced a cluster of README/docs truth gaps:

  1. Every relative link is dead from the install. docs/http-ingest.md, docs/roadmap.md, docs/otel-integration.md, examples/*, CONTRIBUTING.md — none ship in the npm package (only dist/, LICENSE, README.md, server.json). The ingest doc is the designated non-MCP integration path and is unreachable from the artifact that recommends it. Fix: absolute GitHub URLs (like the badges already use), or add docs/ to the files array.
  2. The README never says POST /api/v1/traces lives on the DASHBOARD port (default 6920), not the transport port. First attempt 404s for anyone reading --transport http.
  3. Env-var table lists 9 vars; --help documents ~25. Missing rows include the ones the README itself references (IRIS_ANTHROPIC_API_KEY, IRIS_OPENAI_API_KEY, IRIS_OTEL_ENDPOINT) plus IRIS_HOME, IRIS_NO_AUTO_LAUNCH, IRIS_DASHBOARD_HOST, and the two IRIS_CITATION_* egress switches. Add a drift test comparing the table to the --help block (model on the claims-drift tests).
  4. Security section claims "100 req/min API"; the server enforces and advertises 600 (src/config/defaults.ts). Verified: 120 POSTs in ~15s all 201. Also mirror in docs/architecture.md:474.
  5. Troubleshooting "Version check" recipe is false: --help prints no version and there is no --version flag. Interpolate PKG_VERSION into the help banner + add --version, or change the recipe to --self-test.
  6. --self-test and IRIS_HOME — the two features testers praised most — are undocumented in the README. Add a "Verify your install" line.
  7. Corporate npm install --ignore-scripts breaks the native better-sqlite3 binding and the failure is a 13-path bindings dump. One Troubleshooting line (npm rebuild better-sqlite3) plus a friendlier catch in storage init.
  8. The "Install in Cursor" badge registers the server under the name server (deeplink name=server) instead of iris-eval. README line 4.
  9. No "Authoring a custom rule" section: the definition shape (definition.type values, config keys, weight) is documented only inside the MCP tool description, invisible unless your client renders it.

Found during install-only acceptance testing of the v0.5.0 release candidate (packed tarball, no repo checkout). Part of a 9-issue batch; the blocker + core MAJOR cluster shipped in #365#368 incl. the sandbox in #366.

Activity

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    P1Wrong behaviour or a false claim a user hits on the documented path. Next minor.acceptance-testingFound by an install-only acceptance pass against a packed release (tests/uat)bugSomething isn't workingdocsREADME, docs/, the shipped skill, tool descriptions, CHANGELOG, blogdxDeveloper experience: first-run, errors, ergonomicseffort: mediumHalf day, some familiarity needed

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

      Relationships

      None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

      Issue actions